FRIENDS WITH BENEFITS – CAN YOU REALLY PULL OFF CASUAL SEX?
The laws of nature dictate that when one sleeps with a member of the opposite sex long enough, they will get emotionally attached. This ladies, is what makes the convenience of having a regular “FB” (and no, I’m not talking about Facebook) virtually impossible.
As a woman who has no current interest in a relationship, I’m not impartial to the odd well timed one night stand. I love leaving the next morning and walking down the street with a bounce in my step looking like the cat that got the cream.
But too many one night stands and I would start to feel like a tart. I could also do without having to navigate strange men’s bedrooms praying that they have clean sheets; avoiding the awkward exchanges with their flatmates in the hallway whilst running to the toilet in the middle of the night with nothing but a sheet wrapped around my naked body; and also searching for my knickers in the cold hard light of day, so I can put the rest of my clothes on and get into a taxi.
Enter the FWB – Friends With Benefits. Whereas an FB is a straight sexual transaction (you’ll be pushing it to get breakfast in the morning), the FWB is no strings attached sex, but with the added bonus of being able to go to a movie together, do dinner and have an actual friendship. The FWB is one step away from the SBF (surrogate boyfriend), but that’s another story in itself.
But it’s usually nothing more than a concept, because in reality it will nearly always go pear shaped (just ask Jerry and Elaine). However, occasionally, v. occasionally, someone is able to pull off casual sex without eventually wanting more than a good shag on Wednesday night. Yes, they can act like a lady, yet have sex like a man (thanks to Steve Harvey for helping me to coin that phrase).
Well, that woman is me. Somehow in my 30s, I have the act of casual sex down to an art form. I can do the mercy shag with a friend, have one night stands and even repeat sex with the same person, without getting emotionally attached. How do I do it? Besides being rather emotionally closed off to romance, I know how to choose the right subjects and how to outsmart oxytocin. Oxy what, you ask? Well, there’ll be more of that in my book (I do apologise for being like a reality TV show – “we’ll be back just after this break to tell you whose been evicted”, but I know you’ll forgive me).
I’ve had my FWB since 2007. We’re the best of friends, hang out, look out for each other, and, oh, we have sex too. He’s the relationship without the relationship. Now, many of my friends think he is a real catch – and he is. But we could never be with each other romantically, and we both get that. We are more like best friends on school camp together, sneaking up to the top bunk in the middle of the night with our torches and counting out our lollies together . I am sure if we hung out when we were 8, we would have ridden down to the lake together to catch tadpoles after school. Oh, and, yes, we do a lot of laughing together. Like last night when we walked down to the 7/11 in the middle of the night to buy slurpies, whilst retelling jokes from the Steve Harvey stand up we had just watched.
There is no romantic commitment and we’re both free to sleep with other people (but our friends are off limits, because that would be just wrong). Not that we do sleep with other people all that often, because, let me tell you, we got it going on in the bedroom. There’s no head damage, no expectations of each other, no hour long phone calls to friends analysisng where it’s going, and wondering if one of us has feelings for each other (yes folks, I did that a lot in my 20s). And, no, I’m not in denial. It just is.
Come on, surely there must be a chance between the two of you? Everything sounds so peachy keen, you must have thought about something more with him. Well, sure, I am sure both of us would have considered it at some stage early on, but now, we both emphatically know that we’d drive each other nuts. Like really nuts. I could tell you all the ways he irritates the hell out of me, and the things I do that get him going, but then we’d just sound like an old married couple. We’re just wired differently, and we accept that. I like calm and easygoing, and he can be uptight ( he would beg to differ and will probably yell out, no, I’m not, when he reads this, but he is). Don’t worry, it won’t end our friendship, actually, it’s a bit of an injoke between us.
Sure, I will probably flip out when he meets someone who he wants to be in a relationship with (I know Katie is on standby for that phone call), and vice versa . That’s only natural. There’s still a bond between us that will be broken when one of us finds someone else, but we’ll both genuinely be happy for each other. Because he deserves someone special, and he feels the same way about me.
Ultimately the reason our arrangement works is because of who we both are and where we are both at, and I concede it’s a rare combination. I too have tried casual sex in the past (namely my 20s) and seen the best of intentions unravel. The key to a successful casual sex arrangement is choosing the right person, who understands that there also needs to be respect in the situation, which is why I much prefer an FWB to an FB in my hour of need.
Image source
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3266/2696327511_23c69e00b8.jpg





i can relate in a very big way to this story miss gaynor!
Great article! You are one strong lady – and wise too.
I tried the FB thing & the FWB thing, but unfortunately, both ended in tears, from both parties. In my 20s, I had a number of FBs, and in my early 30s, I had a number of FWBs.
The FBs, like you said, were easy – I was able to come and go as I pleased, as that was the arrangement. Sadly, though, 1 FB didn’t see our relationship as that, which made me wonder if he fully understood our arrangement. So I steered clear of FBs after that.
I have been blessed enough to have found the love of my life, but the last “relationship” I had before meeting my J was a long standing FWB. Well, at least, that’s what he thought, but I started to fall for him, which meant I was breaking our arrangement. I had to pull back from seeing him because I was, for some reason, waiting for him to realise I was falling for him, and knew that the feelings were not reciprocated.
After I met J, my FWB and I tried to go back to being friends, but things were never really the same. Until one night, he came over and told me that he couldn’t see me any more because it was hurting him to see me with J, and that he was in love with me and I was always the one – it just took him until I met J to realise that I was “the one” for him. Tears all round – him because he couldn’t have me, and me because it was in a small way, I felt guilty that I now didn’t love him the way I love my J.
If I didn’t have J, I don’t think I’d be brave enough to venture into another FWB thing. I’m not strong enough to differentiate that line, and I know eventually I’d end up hurting myself again.
Gloria – Yes, it usually does end up going pear shaped because someone ends up developing feelings for each other. I think the reason my situation works is that we both irritate the hell out of each too much to be with each other, but we will always be besties
I think you were lucky that your FWB was what I like to call a slow learner, because if he had reciprocated the feelings at the time, then you wouldn’t have met J. Aaaah, life always seems to have a funny way of working out doesn’t it?
Yes, casual sex does require some bravery, and often you need to pull out just in time (pardon the pun) before one of you gets too close.
I hear this friends with benefits term thrown around all the time, but I can’t relate at all. The thought of sleeping with someone who doesn’t send your heart fluttering is just foreign to me, and of course if he does send your heart fluttering then he’s not really in the fwb category since you’re hoping for more. Of course I’ve been married for many years and was a true romantic before that, which clouds my opinion tremendously.
HI Tina – thanks for posting a comment
It’s always great to hear different points of view. Fabulous to hear that you found your knight in shining armour
)